|
|
Эта страница руководства является частью версии 5.0 Инструментов XCodeПолучить эти инструменты:
Если Вы выполняете версию Инструментов XCode кроме 5,0, просматриваете документацию локально:
Читать страницы руководстваСтраницы руководства предназначаются как справочник для людей, уже понимающих технологию.
|
PPI(3) User Contributed Perl Documentation PPI(3)
NAME
PPI - Parse, Analyze and Manipulate Perl (without perl)
SYNOPSIS
use PPI;
# Create a new empty document
my $Document = PPI::Document->new;
# Create a document from source
$Document = PPI::Document->new(\'print "Hello World!\n"');
# Load a Document from a file
$Document = PPI::Document->new('Module.pm');
# Does it contain any POD?
if ( $Document->find_any('PPI::Token::Pod') ) {
print "Module contains POD\n";
}
# Get the name of the main package
$pkg = $Document->find_first('PPI::Statement::Package')->namespace;
# Remove all that nasty documentation
$Document->prune('PPI::Token::Pod');
$Document->prune('PPI::Token::Comment');
# Save the file
$Document->save('Module.pm.stripped');
DESCRIPTION
About this Document
This is the PPI manual. It describes its reason for existing, its general structure, its use, an
overview of the API, and provides a few implementation samples.
Background
The ability to read, and manipulate Perl (the language) programmatically other than with perl (the
application) was one that caused difficulty for a long time.
The cause of this problem was Perl's complex and dynamic grammar. Although there is typically not a
huge diversity in the grammar of most Perl code, certain issues cause large problems when it comes to
parsing.
Indeed, quite early in Perl's history Tom Christenson introduced the Perl community to the quote
"Nothing but perl can parse Perl", or as it is more often stated now as a truism:
"Only perl can parse Perl"
One example of the sorts of things the prevent Perl being easily parsed are function signatures, as
demonstrated by the following.
@result = (dothis $foo, $bar);
# Which of the following is it equivalent to?
@result = (dothis($foo), $bar);
@result = dothis($foo, $bar);
The first line above can be interpreted in two different ways, depending on whether the &dothis
function is expecting one argument, or two, or several.
A "code parser" (something that parses for the purpose of execution) such as perl needs information
that is not found in the immediate vicinity of the statement being parsed.
The information might not just be elsewhere in the file, it might not even be in the same file at
all. It might also not be able to determine this information without the prior execution of a "BEGIN
{}" block, or the loading and execution of one or more external modules. Or worse the &dothis
function may not even have been written yet.
When parsing Perl as code, you must also execute it
Even perl itself never really fully understands the structure of the source code after and indeed as
it processes it, and in that sense doesn't "parse" Perl source into anything remotely like a
structured document. This makes it of no real use for any task that needs to treat the source code
as a document, and do so reliably and robustly.
For more information on why it is impossible to parse perl, see Randal Schwartz's seminal response to
the question of "Why can't you parse Perl".
<http://www.perlmonks.org/index.pl?node_id=44722>
The purpose of PPI is not to parse Perl Code, but to parse Perl Documents. By treating the problem
this way, we are able to parse a single file containing Perl source code "isolated" from any other
resources, such as libraries upon which the code may depend, and without needing to run an instance
of perl alongside or inside the parser.
Historically, using an embedded perl parser was widely considered to be the most likely avenue for
finding a solution to "Parse::Perl". It was investigated from time to time and attempts have
generally failed or suffered from sufficiently bad corner cases that they were abandoned.
What Does PPI Stand For?
"PPI" is an acronym for the longer original module name "Parse::Perl::Isolated". And in the spirit or
the silly acronym games played by certain unnamed Open Source projects you may have hurd of, it also
a reverse backronym of "I Parse Perl".
Of course, I could just be lying and have just made that second bit up 10 minutes before the release
of PPI 1.000. Besides, all the cool Perl packages have TLAs (Three Letter Acronyms). It's a rule or
something.
Why don't you just think of it as the Perl Parsing Interface for simplicity.
The original name was shortened to prevent the author (and you the users) from contracting RSI by
having to type crazy things like "Parse::Perl::Isolated::Token::QuoteLike::Backtick" 100 times a day.
In acknowledgment that someone may some day come up with a valid solution for the grammar problem it
was decided at the commencement of the project to leave the "Parse::Perl" namespace free for any such
effort.
Since that time I've been able to prove to my own satisfaction that it is truly impossible to
accurately parse Perl as both code and document at once. For the academics, parsing Perl suffers from
the "Halting Problem".
With this in mind "Parse::Perl" has now been co-opted as the title for the SourceForge project that
publishes PPI and a large collection of other applications and modules related to the (document)
parsing of Perl source code.
You can find this project at <http://sf.net/projects/parseperl>, however we no longer use the
SourceForge CVS server. Instead, the current development version of PPI is available via SVN at
<http://svn.ali.as/cpan/trunk/PPI/>.
Why Parse Perl?
Once you can accept that we will never be able to parse Perl well enough to meet the standards of
things that treat Perl as code, it is worth re-examining "why" we want to "parse" Perl at all.
What are the things that people might want a "Perl parser" for.
Documentation
Analyzing the contents of a Perl document to automatically generate documentation, in parallel
to, or as a replacement for, POD documentation.
Allow an indexer to to locate and process all the comments and documentation from code for "full
text search" applications.
Structural and Quality Analysis
Determine quality or other metrics across a body of code, and identify situations relating to
particular phrases, techniques or locations.
Index functions, variables and packages within Perl code, and doing search and graph (in the
node/edge sense) analysis of large code bases.
Refactoring
Make structural, syntax, or other changes to code in an automated manner, either independently or
in assistance to an editor. This sort of task list includes backporting, forward porting, partial
evaluation, "improving" code, or whatever. All the sort of things you'd want from a Perl::Editor.
Layout
Change the layout of code without changing its meaning. This includes techniques such as tidying
(like perltidy), obfuscation, compressing and "squishing", or to implement formatting preferences
or policies.
Presentation
This includes methods of improving the presentation of code, without changing the content of the
code. Modify, improve, syntax colour etc the presentation of a Perl document. Generating
"IntelliText"-like functions.
If we treat this as a baseline for the sort of things we are going to have to build on top of Perl,
then it becomes possible to identify a standard for how good a Perl parser needs to be.
How good is Good Enough(TM)
PPI seeks to be good enough to achieve all of the above tasks, or to provide a sufficiently good API
on which to allow others to implement modules in these and related areas.
However, there are going to be limits to this process. Because PPI cannot adapt to changing grammars,
any code written using source filters should not be assumed to be parsable.
At one extreme, this includes anything munged by Acme::Bleach, as well as (arguably) more common
cases like Switch. We do not pretend to be able to always parse code using these modules, although as
long as it still follows a format that looks like Perl syntax, it may be possible to extend the lexer
to handle them.
The ability to extend PPI to handle lexical additions to the language is on the drawing board to be
done some time post-1.0
The goal for success was originally to be able to successfully parse 99% of all Perl documents
contained in CPAN. This means the entire file in each case.
PPI has succeeded in this goal far beyond the expectations of even the author. At time of writing
there are only 28 non-Acme Perl modules in CPAN that PPI is incapable of parsing. Most of these are
so badly broken they do not compile as Perl code anyway.
So unless you are actively going out of your way to break PPI, you should expect that it will handle
your code just fine.
Internationalisation
PPI provides partial support for internationalisation and localisation.
Specifically, it allows the use characters from the Latin-1 character set to be used in quotes,
comments, and POD. Primarily, this covers languages from Europe and South America.
PPI does not currently provide support for Unicode, although there is an initial implementation
available in a development branch from CVS.
If you need Unicode support, and would like to help stress test the Unicode support so we can move it
to the main branch and enable it in the main release should contact the author. (contact details
below)
Round Trip Safe
When PPI parses a file it builds everything into the model, including whitespace. This is needed in
order to make the Document fully "Round Trip" safe.
The general concept behind a "Round Trip" parser is that it knows what it is parsing is somewhat
uncertain, and so expects to get things wrong from time to time. In the cases where it parses code
wrongly the tree will serialize back out to the same string of code that was read in, repairing the
parser's mistake as it heads back out to the file.
The end result is that if you parse in a file and serialize it back out without changing the tree,
you are guaranteed to get the same file you started with. PPI does this correctly and reliably for
100% of all known cases.
What goes in, will come out. Every time.
The one minor exception at this time is that if the newlines for your file are wrong (meaning not
matching the platform newline format), PPI will localise them for you. (It isn't to be convenient,
supporting arbitrary newlines would make some of the code more complicated)
Better control of the newline type is on the wish list though, and anyone wanting to help out is
encouraged to contact the author.
IMPLEMENTATION
General Layout
PPI is built upon two primary "parsing" components, PPI::Tokenizer and PPI::Lexer, and a large tree
of about 50 classes which implement the various the Perl Document Object Model (PDOM).
The PDOM is conceptually similar in style and intent to the regular DOM or other code Abstract Syntax
Trees (ASTs), but contains some differences to handle perl-specific cases, and to assist in treating
the code as a document. Please note that it is not an implementation of the official Document Object
Model specification, only somewhat similar to it.
On top of the Tokenizer, Lexer and the classes of the PDOM, sit a number of classes intended to make
life a little easier when dealing with PDOM trees.
Both the major parsing components were hand-coded from scratch with only plain Perl code and a few
small utility modules. There are no grammar or patterns mini-languages, no YACC or LEX style tools
and only a small number of regular expressions.
This is primarily because of the sheer volume of accumulated cruft that exists in Perl. Not even perl
itself is capable of parsing Perl documents (remember, it just parses and executes it as code).
As a result, PPI needed to be cruftier than perl itself. Feel free to shudder at this point, and hope
you never have to understand the Tokenizer codebase. Speaking of which...
The Tokenizer
The Tokenizer takes source code and converts it into a series of tokens. It does this using a slow
but thorough character by character manual process, rather than using a pattern system or complex
regexes.
Or at least it does so conceptually. If you were to actually trace the code you would find it's not
truly character by character due to a number of regexps and optimisations throughout the code. This
lets the Tokenizer "skip ahead" when it can find shortcuts, so it tends to jump around a line a bit
wildly at times.
In practice, the number of times the Tokenizer will actually move the character cursor itself is only
about 5% - 10% higher than the number of tokens contained in the file. This makes it about as optimal
as it can be made without implementing it in something other than Perl.
In 2001 when PPI was started, this structure made PPI quite slow, and not really suitable for
interactive tasks. This situation has improved greatly with multi-gigahertz processors, but can still
be painful when working with very large files.
The target parsing rate for PPI is about 5000 lines per gigacycle. It is currently believed to be at
about 1500, and main avenue for making it to the target speed has now become PPI::XS, a drop-in XS
accelerator for PPI.
Since PPI::XS has only just gotten off the ground and is currently only at proof-of-concept stage,
this may take a little while. Anyone interested in helping out with PPI::XS is highly encouraged to
contact the author. In fact, the design of PPI::XS means it's possible to port one function at a time
safely and reliably. So every little bit will help.
The Lexer
The Lexer takes a token stream, and converts it to a lexical tree. Because we are parsing Perl
documents this includes whitespace, comments, and all number of weird things that have no relevance
when code is actually executed.
An instantiated PPI::Lexer consumes PPI::Tokenizer objects and produces PPI::Document objects.
However you should probably never be working with the Lexer directly. You should just be able to
create PPI::Document objects and work with them directly.
The Perl Document Object Model
The PDOM is a structured collection of data classes that together provide a correct and scalable
model for documents that follow the standard Perl syntax.
The PDOM Class Tree
The following lists all of the 67 current PDOM classes, listing with indentation based on
inheritance.
PPI::Element
PPI::Node
PPI::Document
PPI::Document::Fragment
PPI::Statement
PPI::Statement::Package
PPI::Statement::Include
PPI::Statement::Sub
PPI::Statement::Scheduled
PPI::Statement::Compound
PPI::Statement::Break
PPI::Statement::Given
PPI::Statement::When
PPI::Statement::Data
PPI::Statement::End
PPI::Statement::Expression
PPI::Statement::Variable
PPI::Statement::Null
PPI::Statement::UnmatchedBrace
PPI::Statement::Unknown
PPI::Structure
PPI::Structure::Block
PPI::Structure::Subscript
PPI::Structure::Constructor
PPI::Structure::Condition
PPI::Structure::List
PPI::Structure::For
PPI::Structure::Given
PPI::Structure::When
PPI::Structure::Unknown
PPI::Token
PPI::Token::Whitespace
PPI::Token::Comment
PPI::Token::Pod
PPI::Token::Number
PPI::Token::Number::Binary
PPI::Token::Number::Octal
PPI::Token::Number::Hex
PPI::Token::Number::Float
PPI::Token::Number::Exp
PPI::Token::Number::Version
PPI::Token::Word
PPI::Token::DashedWord
PPI::Token::Symbol
PPI::Token::Magic
PPI::Token::ArrayIndex
PPI::Token::Operator
PPI::Token::Quote
PPI::Token::Quote::Single
PPI::Token::Quote::Double
PPI::Token::Quote::Literal
PPI::Token::Quote::Interpolate
PPI::Token::QuoteLike
PPI::Token::QuoteLike::Backtick
PPI::Token::QuoteLike::Command
PPI::Token::QuoteLike::Regexp
PPI::Token::QuoteLike::Words
PPI::Token::QuoteLike::Readline
PPI::Token::Regexp
PPI::Token::Regexp::Match
PPI::Token::Regexp::Substitute
PPI::Token::Regexp::Transliterate
PPI::Token::HereDoc
PPI::Token::Cast
PPI::Token::Structure
PPI::Token::Label
PPI::Token::Separator
PPI::Token::Data
PPI::Token::End
PPI::Token::Prototype
PPI::Token::Attribute
PPI::Token::Unknown
To summarize the above layout, all PDOM objects inherit from the PPI::Element class.
Under this are PPI::Token, strings of content with a known type, and PPI::Node, syntactically
significant containers that hold other Elements.
The three most important of these are the PPI::Document, the PPI::Statement and the PPI::Structure
classes.
The Document, Statement and Structure
At the top of all complete PDOM trees is a PPI::Document object. It represents a complete file of
Perl source code as you might find it on disk.
There are some specialised types of document, such as PPI::Document::File and
PPI::Document::Normalized but for the purposes of the PDOM they are all just considered to be the
same thing.
Each Document will contain a number of Statements, Structures and Tokens.
A PPI::Statement is any series of Tokens and Structures that are treated as a single contiguous
statement by perl itself. You should note that a Statement is as close as PPI can get to "parsing"
the code in the sense that perl-itself parses Perl code when it is building the op-tree.
Because of the isolation and Perl's syntax, it is provably impossible for PPI to accurately determine
precedence of operators or which tokens are implicit arguments to a sub call.
So rather than lead you on with a bad guess that has a strong chance of being wrong, PPI does not
attempt to determine precedence or sub parameters at all.
At a fundamental level, it only knows that this series of elements represents a single Statement as
perl sees it, but it can do so with enough certainty that it can be trusted.
However, for specific Statement types the PDOM is able to derive additional useful information about
their meaning. For the best, most useful, and most heavily used example, see PPI::Statement::Include.
A PPI::Structure is any series of tokens contained within matching braces. This includes code
blocks, conditions, function argument braces, anonymous array and hash constructors, lists, scoping
braces and all other syntactic structures represented by a matching pair of braces, including
(although it may not seem obvious at first) "<READLINE>" braces.
Each Structure contains none, one, or many Tokens and Structures (the rules for which vary for the
different Structure subclasses)
Under the PDOM structure rules, a Statement can never directly contain another child Statement, a
Structure can never directly contain another child Structure, and a Document can never contain
another Document anywhere in the tree.
Aside from these three rules, the PDOM tree is extremely flexible.
The PDOM at Work
To demonstrate the PDOM in use lets start with an example showing how the tree might look for the
following chunk of simple Perl code.
#!/usr/bin/perl
print( "Hello World!" );
exit();
Translated into a PDOM tree it would have the following structure (as shown via the included
PPI::Dumper).
PPI::Document
PPI::Token::Comment '#!/usr/bin/perl\n'
PPI::Token::Whitespace '\n'
PPI::Statement::Expression
PPI::Token::Bareword 'print'
PPI::Structure::List ( ... )
PPI::Token::Whitespace ' '
PPI::Statement::Expression
PPI::Token::Quote::Double '"Hello World!"'
PPI::Token::Whitespace ' '
PPI::Token::Structure ';'
PPI::Token::Whitespace '\n'
PPI::Token::Whitespace '\n'
PPI::Statement::Expression
PPI::Token::Bareword 'exit'
PPI::Structure::List ( ... )
PPI::Token::Structure ';'
PPI::Token::Whitespace '\n'
Please note that in this this example, strings are only listed for the actual PPI::Token that
contains that string. Structures are listed with the type of brace characters it represents noted.
The PPI::Dumper module can be used to generate similar trees yourself.
We can make that PDOM dump a little easier to read if we strip out all the whitespace. Here it is
again, sans the distracting whitespace tokens.
PPI::Document
PPI::Token::Comment '#!/usr/bin/perl\n'
PPI::Statement::Expression
PPI::Token::Bareword 'print'
PPI::Structure::List ( ... )
PPI::Statement::Expression
PPI::Token::Quote::Double '"Hello World!"'
PPI::Token::Structure ';'
PPI::Statement::Expression
PPI::Token::Bareword 'exit'
PPI::Structure::List ( ... )
PPI::Token::Structure ';'
As you can see, the tree can get fairly deep at time, especially when every isolated token in a
bracket becomes its own statement. This is needed to allow anything inside the tree the ability to
grow. It also makes the search and analysis algorithms much more flexible.
Because of the depth and complexity of PDOM trees, a vast number of very easy to use methods have
been added wherever possible to help people working with PDOM trees do normal tasks relatively
quickly and efficiently.
Overview of the Primary Classes
The main PPI classes, and links to their own documentation, are listed here in alphabetical order.
PPI::Document
The Document object, the root of the PDOM.
PPI::Document::Fragment
A cohesive fragment of a larger Document. Although not of any real current use, it is needed for
use in certain internal tree manipulation algorithms.
For example, doing things like cut/copy/paste etc. Very similar to a PPI::Document, but has some
additional methods and does not represent a lexical scope boundary.
A document fragment is also non-serializable, and so cannot be written out to a file.
PPI::Dumper
A simple class for dumping readable debugging versions of PDOM structures, such as in the
demonstration above.
PPI::Element
The Element class is the abstract base class for all objects within the PDOM
PPI::Find
Implements an instantiable object form of a PDOM tree search.
PPI::Lexer
The PPI Lexer. Converts Token streams into PDOM trees.
PPI::Node
The Node object, the abstract base class for all PDOM objects that can contain other Elements,
such as the Document, Statement and Structure objects.
PPI::Statement
The base class for all Perl statements. Generic "evaluate for side-effects" statements are of
this actual type. Other more interesting statement types belong to one of its children.
See it's own documentation for a longer description and list of all of the different statement
types and sub-classes.
PPI::Structure
The abstract base class for all structures. A Structure is a language construct consisting of
matching braces containing a set of other elements.
See the PPI::Structure documentation for a description and list of all of the different structure
types and sub-classes.
PPI::Token
A token is the basic unit of content. At its most basic, a Token is just a string tagged with
metadata (its class, and some additional flags in some cases).
PPI::Token::_QuoteEngine
The PPI::Token::Quote and PPI::Token::QuoteLike classes provide abstract base classes for the
many and varied types of quote and quote-like things in Perl. However, much of the actual quote
login is implemented in a separate quote engine, based at PPI::Token::_QuoteEngine.
Classes that inherit from PPI::Token::Quote, PPI::Token::QuoteLike and PPI::Token::Regexp are
generally parsed only by the Quote Engine.
PPI::Tokenizer
The PPI Tokenizer. One Tokenizer consumes a chunk of text and provides access to a stream of
PPI::Token objects.
The Tokenizer is very very complicated, to the point where even the author treads carefully when
working with it.
Most of the complication is the result of optimizations which have tripled the tokenization
speed, at the expense of maintainability. We cope with the spaghetti by heavily commenting
everything.
PPI::Transform
The Perl Document Transformation API. Provides a standard interface and abstract base class for
objects and classes that manipulate Documents.
INSTALLING
The core PPI distribution is pure Perl and has been kept as tight as possible and with as few
dependencies as possible.
It should download and install normally on any platform from within the CPAN and CPANPLUS
applications, or directly using the distribution tarball. If installing by hand, you may need to
install a few small utility modules first. The exact ones will depend on your version of perl.
There are no special install instructions for PPI, and the normal "Perl Makefile.PL", "make", "make
test", "make install" instructions apply.
EXTENDING
The PPI namespace itself is reserved for the sole use of the modules under the umbrella of the
"Parse::Perl" SourceForge project.
<http://sf.net/projects/parseperl>
You are recommended to use the PPIx:: namespace for PPI-specific modifications or prototypes thereof,
or Perl:: for modules which provide a general Perl language-related functions.
If what you wish to implement looks like it fits into PPIx:: namespace, you should consider
contacting the "Parse::Perl" mailing list (detailed on the SourceForge site) first, as what you want
may already be in progress, or you may wish to consider joining the team and doing it within the
"Parse::Perl" project itself.
TO DO
- Many more analysis and utility methods for PDOM classes
- Creation of a PPI::Tutorial document
- Add many more key functions to PPI::XS
- We can always write more and better unit tests
- Complete the full implementation of ->literal (1.200)
- Full understanding of scoping (due 1.300)
SUPPORT
This module is stored in an Open Repository at the following address.
<http://svn.ali.as/cpan/trunk/PPI>
Write access to the repository is made available automatically to any published CPAN author, and to
most other volunteers on request.
If you are able to submit your bug report in the form of new (failing) unit tests, or can apply your
fix directly instead of submitting a patch, you are strongly encouraged to do so, as the author
currently maintains over 100 modules and it can take some time to deal with non-"Critical" bug
reports or patches.
This will also guarentee that your issue will be addressed in the next release of the module.
For large changes though, please consider creating a branch so that they can be properly reviewed and
trialed before being applied to the trunk.
If you cannot provide a direct test or fix, or don't have time to do so, then regular bug reports are
still accepted and appreciated via the CPAN bug tracker.
<http://rt.cpan.org/NoAuth/ReportBug.html?Queue=PPI>
For other issues or questions, contact the "Parse::Perl" project mailing list.
For commercial or media-related enquiries, or to have your SVN commit bit enabled, contact the
author.
AUTHOR
Adam Kennedy <adamk@cpan.org>
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
A huge thank you to Phase N Australia (http://phase-n.com/ <http://phase-n.com/>) for permitting the
original open sourcing and release of this distribution from what was originally several thousand
hours of commercial work.
Another big thank you to The Perl Foundation (<http://www.perlfoundation.org/>) for funding for the
final big refactoring and completion run.
Also, to the various co-maintainers that have contributed both large and small with tests and patches
and especially to those rare few who have deep-dived into the guts to (gasp) add a feature.
- Dan Brook : PPIx::XPath, Acme::PerlML
- Audrey Tang : "Line Noise" Testing
- Arjen Laarhoven : Three-element ->location support
- Elliot Shank : Perl 5.10 support, five-element ->location
And finally, thanks to those brave ( and foolish :) ) souls willing to dive in and use, test drive
and provide feedback on PPI before version 1.000, in some cases before it made it to beta quality,
and still did extremely distasteful things (like eating 50 meg of RAM a second).
I owe you all a beer. Corner me somewhere and collect at your convenience. If I missed someone who
wasn't in my email history, thank you too :)
# In approximate order of appearance
- Claes Jacobsson
- Michael Schwern
- Jeff T. Parsons
- CPAN Author "CHOCOLATEBOY"
- Robert Rotherberg
- CPAN Author "PODMASTER"
- Richard Soderberg
- Nadim ibn Hamouda el Khemir
- Graciliano M. P.
- Leon Brocard
- Jody Belka
- Curtis Ovid
- Yuval Kogman
- Michael Schilli
- Slaven Rezic
- Lars Thegler
- Tony Stubblebine
- Tatsuhiko Miyagawa
- CPAN Author "CHROMATIC"
- Matisse Enzer
- Roy Fulbright
- Dan Brook
- Johnny Lee
- Johan Lindstrom
And to single one person out, thanks go to Randal Schwartz who spent a great number of hours in IRC
over a critical 6 month period explaining why Perl is impossibly unparsable and constantly shoving
evil and ugly corner cases in my face. He remained a tireless devil's advocate, and without his
support this project genuinely could never have been completed.
So for my schooling in the Deep Magiks, you have my deepest gratitude Randal.
COPYRIGHT
Copyright 2001 - 2011 Adam Kennedy.
This program is free software; you can redistribute it and/or modify it under the same terms as Perl
itself.
The full text of the license can be found in the LICENSE file included with this module.
perl v5.16.2 2011-02-25 PPI(3)
|
Сообщение о проблемах
Способ сообщить о проблеме с этой страницей руководства зависит от типа проблемы:
- Ошибки содержания
- Ошибки отчета в содержании этой документации к проекту Perl. (См. perlbug (1) для инструкций представления.)
- Отчеты об ошибках
- Сообщите об ошибках в функциональности описанного инструмента или API к Apple через Генератор отчетов Ошибки и к проекту Perl, использующему perlbug (1).
- Форматирование проблем
- Отчет, форматирующий ошибки в интерактивной версии этих страниц со ссылками на отзыв ниже.